Blood Alley
a new novel by
Tom Coffey

Blood Alley ran along the East River in the Turtle Bay section of Manhattan. Wedged between the affluent enclaves of Tudor City and Murray Hill to the south, and Beekman Place and Sutton Place to the north, with the Third Avenue El on its western edge, it was a six-block long eyesore of slaughterhouses, breweries and tenements. The juxtaposition of high-end Manhattan society right alongside the city’s most grinding poverty made this part of New York the setting for the groundbreaking play and movie “Dead End.”

The economic crisis of the Depression gave Fiorello La Guardia and Robert Moses the opportunity to remake large sections of New York. Slums were cleared, roads were built, parks were constructed and many of the elevated trains that loomed over Manhattan’s north-south avenues were torn down. World War II brought an abrupt end to this civic engineering, as all public and private efforts shifted toward the war effort. That left one high-profile but still blighted area unaffected: Blood Alley.

Enter the United Nations. With World War II over, the Allies were determined to secure the peace. The League of Nations had failed, and the victorious countries were determined to make its successor effective. The United States, famously, had rejected the League. This time around, political and diplomatic leaders around the world believed that the United States had to join, and lead, the postwar international organization. One of the ways to ensure this was to locate the U.N. in the United States -- instead of, say, Switzerland, where the League of Nations had its headquarters.

The U.N. Charter was signed in San Francisco, and Harry Truman offered the Presidio as a site for the organization. But the Europeans turned Truman down. For them, the West Coast was too far away. (Imagine rejecting free real estate in San Francisco; it truly was a different era.)

Forced to concentrate on the East Coast, U.N. officials set up temporary shop in the New York area, with various departments and functions scattered around Manhattan, the Bronx, Westchester and Lake Success. The need for a central headquarters was both obvious and pressing. So was the U.N.’s desire to stay in New York. But the city had no place to offer, and the U.N. began to explore sites in Boston and Philadelphia, with a Main Line location eventually becoming the most attractive.

Re-enter Blood Alley. During the war, real estate developer William Zeckendorf had quietly bought up much of the property in the area. With the war over, ambitious public and private plans could move forward, and Zeckendorf announced his intention to build something he called X-City, a blocks-long, multi-acre development with office towers, residential buildings and cultural facilities, including the long-sought new home of the Metropolitan Opera.

 That sounded like an updated version of Rockefeller Center. Which was exactly Zeckendorf’s intention. He wanted to compete with the Rockefellers’ Midtown Art Deco jewel, although there was considerable doubt about whether he had the capital to do so.

Instead of calling Zeckendorf’s bluff, the Rockefellers decided to buy him out. With the U.N. poised to announce that it was moving to Philadelphia, the Rockefellers purchased the property Zeckendorf had painstakingly put together, then turned around and donated it to the international organization. (Zeckendorf reportedly made $2.5 million on the transaction -- a nice amount in that era.) It took Robert Moses only four days to execute the legal agreements that would eventually clear the area of slaughterhouses, breweries and tenements. Within five years, the U.N.’s landmark headquarters building had risen along the East River.

The only thing that still blighted the area was the Third Avenue El. It cast a perpetual gloom over a street lined with pawn shops and seedy bars. But the El also provided a vital function, because only one subway line served Manhattan’s East Side. So city officials proposed a deal -- after the El came down, it would be replaced by a subway underneath Second Avenue. 

Experience the Third Avenue El at Forgotten NY.

City voters approved a bond issue to build the subway. The El was demolished, and Third Avenue was redeveloped with office buildings and high-end apartments. With the El gone and the U.N. complex finished, the East Side of Manhattan above 42nd Street became the city’s most desirable location. Various local legends have maintained that the people who helped bring about these changes made an awful lot of money.

Of course, the bond money the voters approved was spent on other things. To this day, the Second Avenue subway remains unbuilt.

Visit our photo gallery
for more pictures
from locales within the novel
Blood Alley.